© 2004 by the American Diabetes Association, Inc.
Effect of Training Status on Regional Disposal of Circulating Free Fatty Acids in the Liver and Skeletal Muscle During Physiological Hyperinsulinemia
1 Turku PET Centre, Department of Nuclear Medicine, University of Turku, Turku, Finland Address correspondence and reprint requests to Patricia Iozzo, MD, Institute of Clinical Physiology, National Research Council (CNR), Via Moruzzi 1, 56100 Pisa, Italy. E-mail: patricia.iozzo{at}ifc.cnr.it
OBJECTIVEFat metabolism is increasingly implicated in the pathogenesis of type 2 diabetes. Endurance training has been shown to prevent hepatic steatosis and to alter skeletal muscle fat metabolism, and regional free fatty acid (FFA) uptake adaptations were suggested as a mechanism. Thus, we tested whether endurance training modifies the uptake of plasma FFAs occurring in the liver and in skeletal muscle during anabolic, i.e., hyperinsulinemic, conditions. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODSTrained and untrained healthy male subjects underwent positron emission tomography scanning of the liver and thigh regions, with the FFA analog 14(R,S)-[18F]fluoro-6-thia-heptadecanoic acid, during euglycemic hyperinsulinemia. Tracer influx rate constants in skeletal muscle (MKi) and liver (LKi) were multiplied by plasma FFA levels to obtain FFA uptake for skeletal muscle (MFU) and liver (LFU), respectively. RESULTSAthletes showed increased VO2max (P < 0.0001), insulin-mediated glucose disposal (M value, 61 ± 4 vs. 46 ± 3 µmol · min1 · kg1, P = 0.01), and plasma lactate levels during the clamp and lower percentage of body fat mass (P = 0.002). MKi was 25% higher in athletes than in sedentary men (P = 0.03). In all subjects, MKi and MFU were positively correlated with the M value (r = 0.56, P = 0.02, and r = 0.51, P = 0.03, respectively) and with plasma lactate levels (r = 0.63, P = 0.006, and r = 0.63, P = 0.005, respectively). LKi was significantly reduced by 20% in the athletes (P = 0.04). By multiple regression, LFU was inversely correlated with the two fitness categories (P = 0.008), and it was lower in athletes. Linear fitting of liver data showed time consistency, indicating no release of FFAs as a mechanism for the reduced liver retention in athletes. CONCLUSIONSWe conclude that endurance training promotes insulin-mediated glucose and FFA disposal in skeletal muscle, while lowering hepatic FFA uptake. Such changes may result in a divergent pattern of fat accumulation in the two organs.
Abbreviations: FFA, free fatty acid LFU, liver FFA uptake MFU, skeletal muscle FFA uptake PET, positron emission tomography ROI, region of interest
Impaired tissue uptake of plasma free fatty acids (FFAs) is an increasingly recognized finding in patients with reduced glucose tolerance (1,2). Changes in lipid metabolism in these subjects also include raised circulating FFA concentrations (3,4) and fat accumulation in nonadipose tissues, such as liver (5) and skeletal muscle (6), both of which have been strongly implicated in the genesis and/or progression of insulin resistance (35). Tissue FFA uptake is driven by substrate delivery and, independently, is stimulated by insulin in skeletal muscle (1,7,8). The intracellular fate of circulating FFAs entering hepatocytes or myocytes is dependent on nutritional status. In general, lipid stores are consumed during fasting and repleted in the postprandial state. Insulin regulates fat metabolism by suppressing lipid oxidation and stimulating FFA incorporation into triglycerides (9). As a consequence, during insulin stimulation FFA release from skeletal muscle becomes negligible (9) and lipid accumulation becomes tightly dependent on FFA uptake. Recent findings (1) confirm the role of insulin in promoting muscle FFA uptake and show that this response is abolished in muscle cells of patients with type 2 diabetes and restored by exposing these cells to thiazolidinediones. Endurance training is generally considered to be protective against the development of metabolic disorders. Current knowledge places the enhancement of insulin sensitivity among the main prevention targets of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (10), and aerobic training has been shown to prevent hepatic steatosis in rats fed a high-fat diet (11). Different from the liver, the apparent paradox of an increased triglyceride and fatty acid binding protein content was described in skeletal muscle of physically trained humans (6,12). Enhanced muscle FFA uptake was suggested as a likely mediator of the accelerated lipid deposition in these subjects. To test the hypothesis that differential uptake of FFA in liver and skeletal muscle (i.e., reduced in liver and enhanced in muscle) might underlie the divergent pattern of fat accumulation observed in athletes, we measured the uptake of serum FFA occurring in these organs under hyperinsulinemic conditions in trained and untrained healthy lean subjects using positron emission tomography (PET) and the FFA analog, 14(R,S)-[18F]fluoro-6-thia-heptadeca-noic acid ([18F]FTHA).
Nine male endurance athletes (e.g., triathletes, runners) and nine healthy sedentary men volunteered for the study. Endurance athletes competed at the national or international level and had engaged in regular endurance exercise for >10 years. Subjects included in the sedentary group did not exercise regularly. All study subjects were healthy, as judged by history, physical examination, and routine laboratory tests. None of the subjects were taking any medication, and all of them were instructed to suspend any physical activity and to consume a low-fat isocaloric diet, including at least 200 g of carbohydrate for 2 days before the study. Written, informed consent was obtained from all subjects after the study protocol had been accepted by the Joint Commission of Ethics of Turku University and Turku University Central Hospital.
PET scanning
Data analysis Regions of interest (ROIs) were placed on two to four different planes within the right lobe of the liver. One to two small ROIs were placed in the left cardiac chamber to obtain blood time-activity curves, and care was taken to avoid spillover from the myocardial wall. For the femoral regions, ROIs were placed on the anterior, medial, and posterior muscle compartments over four adjacent planes. The nonmetabolized fraction of [18F]FTHA was used to correct the input function (8). Blood and muscle or liver time-activity curves were analyzed graphically (15), i.e., they were fitted to a linear equation in which the slope of the fitted line equals the influx rate constant of [18F]FTHA in the liver (LKi) and in skeletal muscle (MKi). FFA uptake indexes in the liver (LFU) and in skeletal muscle (MFU) were estimated by multiplying respective Ki values by mean serum FFA concentrations during PET scanning. For the liver, this represents a minimal estimate, given that the FFA concentration in the portal vein might be slightly higher than that in peripheral blood. To evaluate whether group differences in hepatic tracer retention might depend on tracer outflow from tissue, LKi was fitted over subsequent time intervals, and LFU was calculated accordingly. In this analysis, a progressive decrease in the estimated parameter would indicate tracer loss (16). For skeletal muscle, previous data rule out this mechanism during insulin infusion in healthy subjects (17).
Maximal aerobic power and body fat content
Statistical analysis
Athletes had a lower percentage of fat mass (10 ± 1 vs. 17 ± 1%, P = 0.001) and higher VO2max (67 ± 2 vs. 48 ± 3 ml · min1 · kg1, P < 0.0001) than untrained subjects; the two groups were otherwise well matched for age (28 ± 1 vs. 27 ± 1 years, NS), BMI (21.6 ± 0.5 vs. 22.7 ± 0.6 kg/m2, NS), and circulating substrate-hormone levels (Table 1). Insulin-mediated, whole-body glucose disposal rate was 25% higher in the athletes (Table 1).
MFU The influx rate constant of FFA in skeletal muscle, MKi, was significantly higher (by 25%) in athletes than in sedentary men (Fig. 1); the correspondent 25% increase in MFU (0.128 ± 0.014 vs. 0.168 ± 0.024) fell just short of statistical significance (P = 0.18), due to slightly higher serum FFA levels in sedentary individuals (Fig. 1). Normalizing for this factor [(MFU/individual FFA) x (group average FFA)] led to a significant difference (P = 0.03). In the whole study population, MKi and MFU were positively correlated with plasma lactate levels and whole-body insulin-mediated glucose disposal (r = 0.63, P < 0.01); the latter relationship was mostly accounted for by the trained group (r = 0.65, P = 0.03), and MKi tended to be positively correlated with VO2max (r = 0.45, P = 0.07).
LFU Rapid tracer accumulation was observed in the liver, with a progressive increase of the tissue-to-blood radioactivity ratio. Linear fitting was good, with mean r values of 1.0 ± 0.0 in both groups (NS). Progressive fitting of liver data demonstrated time consistency in both groups, thus excluding the occurrence of tracer release from tissue throughout the scanning period (Fig. 2).
LKi was decreased by 20% in athletes compared with sedentary men (Fig. 1). LFU was also decreased by 20%, but, similar to MFU, the differences achieved significance after being adjusted for circulating FFA levels (P = 0.04). Multiple regression models were fitted to isolate the independent effect of endurance training on LFU. In these models, LFU was introduced as the dependent variable, and its relationships with the two categories of fitness (the independent variable) were examined while accounting for the influence of biochemical and anthropometric characteristics. An independent inverse association was found between the two training levels and LFU (P = 0.008) when adjusting for concurrent plasma lactate and insulin levels. Collectively, the regional differences observed between the two study groups led to a 40% increase in the MFU-to-LFU ratio (per unit of tissue) in trained compared with untrained subjects (Fig. 1).
The present study verified the hypothesis that endurance training is independently associated with an increased uptake of FFAs by skeletal muscle and lower uptake by the liver during hyperinsulinemia. As a result, the MFU-to-LFU ratio was significantly shifted in favor of skeletal muscle in our athlete group. FFA uptake was quantified by PET and [18F]FTHA in the present study. Notably, circulating FFAs comprise a spectrum of different molecules; FTHA is a 17-carbon FFA analog, and the available comparison with 11C-palmitate supports its use as representative of long-chain fatty acids (18). [18F]FTHA enters mitochondria in proportion to the oxidative rate of FFA (13), but after formation of two acetyl-CoA moieties it cannot be oxidized, due to its sulfur atom, and remains trapped. The amount of tracer entering triglycerides is also mostly retained, considering the short experimental time versus the delay required for the release of newly formed triglycerides. Thus, the FFA uptake observed reflects the sum of both processes because the current technique does not allow their dissection. As compared with the leg balance technique, PET allows one to noninvasively and specifically target regional metabolism, and when limited to the present case, the lack of quantification of each intracellular metabolic pathway and rapid tracer breakdown are relative disadvantages. In the whole organism, with a total muscle mass of 40% of body weight (29 ± 1 kg in our subjects) and an average liver volume of 1.5 l, total MFU and LFU could be estimated from our results to 30% (muscle) and 25% (liver) of total serum FFA turnover, as previously measured in healthy individuals during insulin infusion studies (19). Notably, similar amounts of serum FFA were handled in the two organs despite a 15-fold difference in mass. Previous studies showing that postabsorptive lipid oxidation and skeletal muscle oxidative capacity are higher in trained compared with untrained subjects (6) rule against defective FFA breakdown as a mechanism for skeletal muscle triglyceride accumulation in athletes, and the evidence that muscle triglyceride content was unaffected during exercise led to the hypothesis that concurrent synthesis overrides hydrolysis in male subjects (20). The present study was conducted in the insulinized state, in which FFA oxidation is almost fully suppressed and triglyceride synthesis is enhanced and tightly dependent on FFA uptake. In this situation, we found a 25% increase in MFU and a 20% decrease in LFU in trained versus sedentary individuals. Such changes had been anticipated by previous evidence (12,21); to the best of our knowledge, the present study demonstrates them for the first time in humans. It should be noted that uptake values and group differences shown in the present work would most likely be amplified in a physiological postprandial situation, in which suppression of lipolysis is balanced by the introduction of lipids with the meal, and circulating FFA levels are higher than those during an insulin clamp. In this situation, an enhanced MKi, as observed in our athletes, would support the notion of a causal link between higher MFU and increased FFA transporter/triglyceride content in endurance-trained humans (6,12,21). Further along this line of reasoning, the correlation observed between MFU or MKi and known indicators of fitness, namely insulin-mediated glucose disposal and VO2max, may explain the observed link between muscle FFA transporters/triglyceride content and the degree of endurance training (6,21). The current finding of a downregulation of LFU in athletes is compatible with the concept that higher insulin sensitivity and/or fitness may prevent excessive hepatic fat accumulation (10,11), particularly since the present experiments were conducted in a metabolic state in which hepatic triglyceride synthesis is stimulated and FFA catabolism is inhibited. Though the influence of visceral FFA release on the calculation of LFU could not be assessed, due to the lack of portal measurements, a higher suppression of visceral lipolysis in trained subjects, due to increased insulin sensitivity and decreased abdominal fat mass (22), would amplify the group differences reported here.
Different from findings in type 2 diabetic patients with defective insulin-regulated lipolysis and from (intralipid) studies revealing substrate competition at high serum FFA concentrations (4), our data showed no evidence of reciprocal inhibition between glucose and FFA uptake in skeletal muscle under normally suppressed serum FFA levels. On the contrary, skeletal muscle FFA and whole-body glucose uptake (mainly reflecting muscle uptake) were proportionally increased in all subjects, and they were augmented to the same extent, i.e., by Our findings are relevant to the therapeutic or preventive potential of exercise in patients with, or in those at risk of, type 2 diabetes, in whom numerous metabolic defects involve both glucose and lipid metabolism. In fact, drugs acting to reduce lipid content in the liver of type 2 diabetic subjects improved their glycemic control (5); those drugs were also shown to stimulate MFU in cell cultures (1), though the benefits of such an effect on whole-body metabolic homeostasis could not be explored due to the in vitro study design. In our data, the enhanced removal of circulating FFAs by skeletal muscle in the athletes may be one mechanism by which FFA uptake by other organs, e.g., the liver, was reduced, thus preventing excessive hepatic fat accumulation. The signal(s) for such organ cross-talk remain, however, putative. We conclude that endurance training concertedly promoted insulin-mediated glucose and FFA disposal in skeletal muscle, while lowering hepatic FFA uptake. Consequently, serum FFAs were diverted from the liver to skeletal muscle. Such changes may result into a divergent pattern of fat accumulation in the two organs.
A table elsewhere in this issue shows conventional and Système International (SI) units and conversion factors for many substances. Received for publication December 5, 2003. Accepted for publication June 17, 2004.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||