Advertisement

Measuring Vibration Sensations With Graduated Tuning Fork: Simple and Reliable Means to Detect Diabetic Patients at Risk of Neuropathic Foot Ulceration

  1. Charles Thivolet, MD,
  2. James El Farkh, MD,
  3. Antoinette Petiot, MD,
  4. Chantal Simonet, MD and
  5. Jacques Tourniaire, MD
  1. Endocrinology Branch, Antiquaille Hospital Lyon, France
  1. Address correspondence and reprint requests to Charles H. Thivolet, MD, Clinique Endocrinologique, Hopital de I'Antiquaille, 69321 Lyon, Cedex 05, France.

Abstract

To find a simple and reliable means to measure vibration sensations, 189diabetic patients and 88 control subjects were tested at different sites with a graduated tuning fork. Within-test variation at big toes reached 8.4% in diabetic patients vs. 2.2% in control subjects. Mean contralateral variation was 7.5% in diabetic patients vs. 2.5% in control subjects. Tuning-fork sensations were inversely correlated with duration of diabetes, whereas no correlation was found with HBA1c levels or the severity of retinopathy. Ninety-nine (52%) patients had vibratory sensation at big toes of <99th percentile of normal values for age. In addition, 51% of the patients with clinical symptoms at extremities (n = 67), 70% of the patients without tendon reflexes (n = 50), and 75% of the patients with abnormal nerve conduction velocities (n = 60) also had low vibration sensations. All patients with lower-limb injuries (n = 7) had values at big toes of <2. Altogether, the graduated tuning fork represents a simple and reliable alternative to quantitate vibration sensations. Long-term follow-up of asymptomatic patients willindicate whether these abnormalities reflect underlying neuropathy. Patientswith abnormal values at screening will necessitate additional investigationsand special foot-care education programs.

  • Received June 7, 1989.
  • Revision received March 21, 1990.
  • Accepted March 21, 1990.
| Table of Contents
Advertisement