Scottish Foot Ulcer Risk Score Predicts Foot Ulcer Healing in a Regional Specialist Foot Clinic

  1. Graham Leese, MD (graham.leese{at}tuht.scot.nhs.uk)1,,3,
  2. Christopher Schofield, MB1,
  3. Brian McMurray, DipPod2,
  4. Gillian Libby, BSc3,
  5. Judith Golden, DipPod2,
  6. Ritchie MacAlpine1,
  7. Scott Cunningham3,
  8. Andrew Morris, MD1,,3,
  9. Murray Flett, ChB4 and
  10. Gareth Griffiths, MD4
  1. Ninewells Hospital, Dundee, DD1 9SY1
  2. Dundee Community Health Partnership2, Westgate Health Centre, Dundee
  3. University of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School3
  4. Surgery Ninewells Hospital Dundee4

    Abstract

    AIMS Have patients developing ulcers previously been identified as being at high risk of ulceration using the SCI-DC Ulcer Risk score. Does the risk score predicts ulcer healing.

    METHODS All patients attending the diabetes foot clinic with an ulcer had been assessed for foot ulcer risk using the SCI-DC risk calculator, which categorises patients into low, moderate or high-risk of ulceration. Information on foot pulses, neuropathy, foot deformity, previous ulcer, ulcer site, depth, and presence of sepsis was recorded, and related to ulcer outcome. Patients were followed up until outcome was achieved (median 3 months (range1-33months)).

    RESULTS Of patients attending the clinic with a foot ulcer (mean age 67.3 ±12.7 (SD) years, 68% male), 68% were previously recognised to be at high-risk of foot ulceration, and 98% were high or moderate-risk. Of 221 ulcers, the healing rate was 75% overall, but was lower for high-risk patients compared to other patients (68% vs 93%; p<0.0001). Of the remainder, 3% became chronic ulcers, 12% required minor or major amputation and 10% died with their ulcer. In multivariate analysis, absent pulses, neuropathy, increased age and deep ulcers were associated with poor healing. The combination of neuropathy and ischaemia was particularly associated with poor outcome of an ulcer (61% healing).

    CONCLUSION The Scottish foot ulcer risk score predicts both ulcer development and ulcer healing. The risk score can be a useful initial guide to likely poor healing. The individual criteria contributing to this overall risk are similar to other studies.

    Footnotes

      • Received March 21, 2007.
      • Accepted May 9, 2007.